This concert by the Orchestre jazz des diplômés-es de l’Université de Montréal left its academic mark on the local music scene, with eminent double bassist Ron Carter as the first inaugural guest. The atmosphere at Théâtre Maisonneuve was warm and inviting, with the audience mainly made up of friends, big band family members and music enthusiasts attracted by the concept: the best graduates would perform with the great Ron Carter.
However… Although the set list consisted mainly of Mr. Carter’s original works, arranged by Rich de Rosa and very well played by the orchestra, it was a rather conservative affair, at the very least academic. Very little out of step, in fact, with what one might have heard from a very good modern jazz big band in the ’50s and early ’60s.
Highlights included the lyrical “Little Waltz” and “Ah, Rio”, a bossa nova-inspired composition that was a bit of a game-changer. Although the performance was technically impressive, it felt a little dated, especially considering Ron Carter’s influential role in jazz history – mostly as a performer, very little as a composer. Carter was a leading sideman and player in many movements that pushed the boundaries of jazz and even hip-hop, so it would have been interesting to see a selection of more contemporary and innovative compositions.
Another drawback of the evening was the sound balance. The bass seemed to dominate the mix, sometimes overshadowing the other instruments. While it was undeniably pleasing to hear Mr. Carter’s masterful bass playing, the instrument’s unnaturally high position in the mix prevented full appreciation of the ensemble’s nuances.
Nevertheless, it is essential to recognize the exceptional talent on display last night. Whatever one thinks of it, this concert was an excellent showcase for our own musical masters here in Montreal, highlighting their undeniable skills and dedication to their art.
In fact, it would be pointless and unfair to single out one musician in particular, since all had the opportunity to shine throughout the evening, including Mr. Ron Di Lauro, illustrious U de M professor recently retired after 25 years of loyal service at the helm of this university big band and more.
Before bowing out, he brought out his trumpet for a happy “Little Waltz”.
