Country : United States Label : Pentatone Genres and styles : Contemporary / Contemporary Jazz / Modern Classical Year : 2023

Brad Mehldau/Ian Bostridge – The Folly of Desire

· by Frédéric Cardin

This is a surprising album. Surprising because, on the one hand, jazzophiles will be surprised to see a classical tenor alongside the great jazz pianist Mehldau, and on the other, classical music lovers will be perplexed by the prospect of listening to a new cycle of contemporary lieder by a jazzman. Even if, in the latter case, the surprise is not entirely justified, as Mehldau has already dared this kind of exercise twice before, with Renée Fleming and Anne Sofie von Otter. 

The Folly of Desire touches on a universal subject, sexual desire, but from a… delicate angle. That of lust, sometimes violent. In this age of #metoo, the message conveyed by Mehldau in the programme notes about the retreat of a certain sexual freedom and an invasion of privacy can easily be, shall we say, misperceived. Unless it’s deliberate! I confess I don’t know, and I don’t want to put words in the artist’s mouth. Especially as Mehldau associates the notion of consent with it, which still saves the day. The ambiguity also comes from the fact that these are not his words, but rather those of great authors and poets, all male: Shakespeare, Blake, Yeats, e.e. cummings, Auden, Brecht, Goethe. A perspective that is certainly rooted in the undeniable genius of these authors, but which, combined with the modern context, could easily turn this plea into a missed opportunity to promote a wider range of viewpoints. Let’s not go any further: this is about music, not politics.

The Folly of Desire is a complete cycle, displaying a wide range of emotions and affects, from suffering to anger, from lust (poetically manifested) to regret. The score, either for piano or for Bostridge’s voice, is set in a modernist post-romanticism, bathed in harmonies that are spread out, stretched and complexified by jazz-inspired additions (of course). Bostridge is more than adept at seizing the slightest opportunity to clearly assert an emotion, or to sublimate its intensity. He has his work cut out for him here, especially as Mehldau, a brilliant jazzman but unaccustomed to accompanying a lyric singer, doesn’t always give him the space and time he needs to support and lay down the words. In the end, either he pushes or Bostridge doesn’t follow. In addition, the two friends offer us some very jazz standards (These Foolish Things, Night and Day, and others) as well as a very romantic lied by Schubert (Nacht und Träume). A way for each musician to step out of their usual comfort zone.

Aside from these sweet pieces, which have been adequately rendered, we now find ourselves with a cycle of modern Lieder that certainly raises a lot of questions about its intentions, but which above all offers an incursion into a musical panorama that is dense but highly attractive to future performers who will want to explore all its possibilities and symbolic interstices. After a first listen (and even a second, third, etc.), the real question is not: do I like it or not? Rather, it’s: when will I be able to understand its true meaning?

Latest 360 Content

Le Vivier 2026 | André Pappathomas’ Babel Choir

Le Vivier 2026 | André Pappathomas’ Babel Choir

Still Depths – Alike and Unlike

Still Depths – Alike and Unlike

BUHHHHHH: Give My Remains to Broadway Turn P’tit Ours Into a Darkwave Fever Dream

BUHHHHHH: Give My Remains to Broadway Turn P’tit Ours Into a Darkwave Fever Dream

mary in the junkyard Tosses the Lemon

mary in the junkyard Tosses the Lemon

Bourgie | Sonic Poetry by Bruzzese and Sanchez

Bourgie | Sonic Poetry by Bruzzese and Sanchez

TVOD – The Farm

TVOD – The Farm

Emmanuel Lacopo – Dreamscapes & Our Modern Contradictions

Emmanuel Lacopo – Dreamscapes & Our Modern Contradictions

EkaySounds & Roudy H: Five Chapters, One Story, Two Cultures

EkaySounds & Roudy H: Five Chapters, One Story, Two Cultures

FMA 2026 | Al Qahwa: Music, Memory and a Call for Peace

FMA 2026 | Al Qahwa: Music, Memory and a Call for Peace

Mundial MTL 2026 | Melafrique: Africa for Everyone and by Everyone

Mundial MTL 2026 | Melafrique: Africa for Everyone and by Everyone

Ex:Re – Save As

Ex:Re – Save As

Jacob Do – First Chorus

Jacob Do – First Chorus

Orchestre FILMharmonique/Francis Choinière – A Tribute to John Williams

Orchestre FILMharmonique/Francis Choinière – A Tribute to John Williams

Mathieu Soucy – I Can Dream Can’t I?

Mathieu Soucy – I Can Dream Can’t I?

Mundial MTL 2026 | Orbital Ensemble : steeped into vintage, but with an ear in the present

Mundial MTL 2026 | Orbital Ensemble : steeped into vintage, but with an ear in the present

DIIV – ZIRP!

DIIV – ZIRP!

FMA 2026 | Al Qahwa: The Coffee of Cultures, The Rhythm of Encounters

FMA 2026 | Al Qahwa: The Coffee of Cultures, The Rhythm of Encounters

Baby Berserk – French Manicure

Baby Berserk – French Manicure

Salle Bourgie | Catalyst: a quartet at the peak of its art

Salle Bourgie | Catalyst: a quartet at the peak of its art

Isabella Hallia – A Formal Introduction

Isabella Hallia – A Formal Introduction

Harry Bartlett & Kurtis Perrie – This is Living

Harry Bartlett & Kurtis Perrie – This is Living

Mundial MTL 2026 | Where We Come From, Who We Become: An Interview with Tara Moneka

Mundial MTL 2026 | Where We Come From, Who We Become: An Interview with Tara Moneka

TV Priest – Cartoons

TV Priest – Cartoons

Subscribe to our newsletter

Inscription
Infolettre

"*" indicates required fields

Type of Suscribers