Country : Russia / United Kingdom Label : Chandos Genres and styles : Modern Classical Year : 2024

James Ehnes; BBC Philharmonic / Sir Andrew Davis – Stravinsky : Violin Concerto; Scherzo à la russe; Apollon Musagète; Orchestral Suites

· by Frédéric Cardin

Here is a fine overview of Igor Stravinsky’s neoclassical output, which has nothing to do with the neoclassical style of today’s Ludovico Einaudi, Jean-Michel Blais or Alexandra Streliski. Stravinsky’s neoclassicism draws less on the notion of accessibility (through an almost pop-like harmonic simplicity) than on a return to the architectural form (concerto, sonata, suite, etc.) inherited from the Baroque and Classical periods. This return to basics, shall we say, was, of course, also accompanied by a return to certain harmonic traits and tonal turns reminiscent of the Baroque or Haydnian Classical periods. But, of course, Stravinsky never plunged into this intending to erase his hard-won modernity. The result is an entirely original stylistic synthesis, whose great titles are still celebrated today.

The Violin Concerto, Suites for Orchestra 1 and 2 and Apollon Musagète programmed here are some of the best examples of the style developed by Stravinsky, then imitated by several others, at the turn of the 1920s and 1930s. We could easily have added the neo-baroque Pulcinella and a few other treasures from the composer’s catalogue, but the choice made for this very fine album is consistent in its less-pastiche vision of Stravinsky’s neoclassicism.

The programme is also appreciable in that it juxtaposes works that contrast sharply in terms of sound and timbre. The Concerto, sparkling with energy but quirkily coloured by the abundant and brilliant use of the winds, is in a world of its own vis-à-vis the excerpts from the ballet Apollon Musagète, expansive and amply deployed through its beautiful and long sustained string lines. Between the two, the Orchestral Suites Nos. 1 and 2, in the tradition of the Bach Suites, skilfully blend characters across eight movements (four each) inspired by dances more modern than their Baroque ancestors (like Polka, Waltz, Balalaika, etc.). Also on the list is the peppy Scherzo à la russe, Stravinsky’s gift to Paul Whiteman and his jazz orchestra.

Although the Canadian James Ehnes only appears in the Concerto, it is his name that features prominently on the album cover, testifying to his status as a major international violin star. The violinist with the timbre of a viola (a round, amber sound with great depth) finely sketches out the phrases of the Concerto‘s four movements with energetic fervour. The expressiveness he infuses into the work perhaps goes beyond the ideal framework of a sound space that is intended to be, precisely, anti-romantic. But I find it hard to turn a deaf ear or play the role of a purist snob when faced with such a convincing reading of this masterpiece. The support given by Davis and his splendid orchestra is understanding and appropriate in general, although a certain dichotomy sometimes appears between his ultra-precise approach to orchestration and Ehnes’s more emphatic playing.

There is no risk of any discrepancy in the other pieces on the programme. The BBC Phil shines and has fun with Stravinsky’s scores. The Chandos recording is rich, warm and very natural. 

Latest 360 Content

Blondshell – If You Asked For a Picture

Blondshell – If You Asked For a Picture

Hitting a Fever Pitch at the Ribbon Skirt LP Launch 

Hitting a Fever Pitch at the Ribbon Skirt LP Launch 

Wu-Tang Clan & Mathematics – Black Samson, the Bastard Swordsman.

Wu-Tang Clan & Mathematics – Black Samson, the Bastard Swordsman.

Dalit Hadass Warshaw, Boston Modern Orchestra Project / Gil Rose – Sirens

Dalit Hadass Warshaw, Boston Modern Orchestra Project / Gil Rose – Sirens

Howard Shore/Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France – Shore : Anthology

Howard Shore/Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France – Shore : Anthology

Quatuor Diotima – Boulez : Livre pour quatuor

Quatuor Diotima – Boulez : Livre pour quatuor

LMNL – Rainbow

LMNL – Rainbow

Strat Andriotis – Exits

Strat Andriotis – Exits

Richard Reed Parry – The Actor

Richard Reed Parry – The Actor

Tamara Stefanovich – Organised Delirium

Tamara Stefanovich – Organised Delirium

Galan Trio – Embrace

Galan Trio – Embrace

Jack Van Zandt – A Chaos of Light and Motion

Jack Van Zandt – A Chaos of Light and Motion

Tommy Crane – Reality Curated: Live at Ursa

Tommy Crane – Reality Curated: Live at Ursa

Thomas DeLio – Anti-paysage

Thomas DeLio – Anti-paysage

No Hay Banda – Steven Kazuo Takasugi : Il Teatro Rosso

No Hay Banda – Steven Kazuo Takasugi : Il Teatro Rosso

Vancouver Contemporary Orchestra; Vancouver Chamber Choir – Christopher Tyler Nickel : Mass; Te Deum

Vancouver Contemporary Orchestra; Vancouver Chamber Choir – Christopher Tyler Nickel : Mass; Te Deum

Hypercube – The Force for Good

Hypercube – The Force for Good

PUP – Who Will Look After the Dogs?

PUP – Who Will Look After the Dogs?

Duo AYA – Cycles

Duo AYA – Cycles

Papillon Social Club – Dur de la feuille

Papillon Social Club – Dur de la feuille

Coalescent Quartet – The Wall Between Us

Coalescent Quartet – The Wall Between Us

Samuel Bonnet Trio – Live in Harmony

Samuel Bonnet Trio – Live in Harmony

Marc-André Hamelin; Quatuor Takacs – Dvořák & Price : Piano Quintets

Marc-André Hamelin; Quatuor Takacs – Dvořák & Price : Piano Quintets

Subscribe to our newsletter