Chamber Pop / Indie Pop / Indie Rock / indietronica / Pop / Rock

POP Montréal | We Were Stars

by Lyle Hendriks

It’s hard to place another band that has experienced the trajectory of Montreal-formed indie pop outfit Stars. Celebrating the 20-year anniversary of one of their most iconic albums, Set Yourself On Fire, we were treated to the LP in its entirety, with all the live refinements that come with playing with all original members of the band for more than two decades. 

Stars have a reputation for their unique outlook on their fans, a deep and genuine gratitude that’s earned them a niche but truly hardcore following that hasn’t waned over the years. It was a pleasure to see this attitude firsthand when Stars took the stage in front of a sold-out house in the beautiful Rialto Theatre. Lead vocalist Torquil Campbell exudes a humble grace onstage, looking out upon hundreds of smiling faces with a warmth and kindness that’s hard to put into words. “We wrote these songs for you,” he said, “Because we knew you were out there.”

Stars bring stunning confidence to these old tracks, elevating them even further with the brilliantly placed additions of saxophone and violin, which add an elegant touch of nuance and orchestral beauty to their cavernous tracks. Vocalist and guitarist Amy Millan can hardly stop smiling long enough to deliver her delicate but delicious high-end vocals, while bassist Evan Cranley pounces across the stage with every note. Chris Seligman’s synthesizer work is beautifully moderated, deftly weaving in between hair-raising riffs from Chris McCarron on lead guitar. Millan and Campbell’s voices are true magic together, and when Cranley and Seligman hop on the mic to support, we’re treated to a harmonic feast for the ears.

Of course, it’s hard to compliment the vocals of Stars without mentioning the other guest performers: Nearly every member of the crowd. I found myself awe struck at the sheer dedication and love on display from the audience, who danced, cheered, and sang along in a way that I’ve scarcely seen, even from sold-out arena shows by world-famous musicians. It was so palpable that Stars let us sing the last song of the set, “Calendar Girl” from start to finish, word for word—a beautiful chorus of hundreds of voices coming together over their shared adoration of Stars.

Stars is a phenomenon in the truest sense of the word. What other artist commands such dedication from so many, with such effortless ease? What Canadian indie band boasts the longevity and endurance of this one? Who else rejects the idea of being an idol and instead reflects all the love and gratitude back at us without the slightest hint of irony or cynicism? Stars is a band unlike any other, and it was a pleasure to watch them take this well-deserved victory lap.

Photos by Stephan Boissonneault

Latest 360 Content

Festival de Lanaudière | Leonardo Garcia Alarcon/Monteverdi’s Coronation of Popea: being marketwise

Festival de Lanaudière | Leonardo Garcia Alarcon/Monteverdi’s Coronation of Popea: being marketwise

FIJM | Nate Smith and his Supremely Talented Quartet

FIJM | Nate Smith and his Supremely Talented Quartet

FIJM | Nai Palm? Creature of Exception! Hawa B? Future Star!

FIJM | Nai Palm? Creature of Exception! Hawa B? Future Star!

FIJM 2025 | Funky funky, Trombone Shorty

FIJM 2025 | Funky funky, Trombone Shorty

FIJM | Nubya Garcia Becomes a Star in MTL

FIJM | Nubya Garcia Becomes a Star in MTL

FIJM 2025 | Symphonic Avishai Cohen: Bewitching magic

FIJM 2025 | Symphonic Avishai Cohen: Bewitching magic

King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard – Phantom Island

King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard – Phantom Island

Common Holly – Anything glass

Common Holly – Anything glass

FIJM I Hanorah Sets the TD Stage Ablaze with Soulful R&B

FIJM I Hanorah Sets the TD Stage Ablaze with Soulful R&B

FIJM | Jeff Goldblum: Storyteller, Comedian and Pianist, 3 in 1

FIJM | Jeff Goldblum: Storyteller, Comedian and Pianist, 3 in 1

FIJM I Still Taking Us There, Mavis Staples Electrifies Montreal JazzFest

FIJM I Still Taking Us There, Mavis Staples Electrifies Montreal JazzFest

FIJM | Orchestre Tout Puissant Marcel Duchamp – Ventre Unique

FIJM | Orchestre Tout Puissant Marcel Duchamp – Ventre Unique

Fantastic Negrito – Son of A Broken Man

Fantastic Negrito – Son of A Broken Man

Cumbia, Chaos, and Resistance: Empanadas Illegales Bring the Heat to Montreal Jazz Fest

Cumbia, Chaos, and Resistance: Empanadas Illegales Bring the Heat to Montreal Jazz Fest

Turnstile – Never Enough

Turnstile – Never Enough

FIJM | Meggie Lennon and The Desire Days Story

FIJM | Meggie Lennon and The Desire Days Story

FIJM | Dianne Reeves and Romero Lubambo: An Intimate Duo of Virtuosos

FIJM | Dianne Reeves and Romero Lubambo: An Intimate Duo of Virtuosos

FIJM | Brandon Woody’s Upendo: Baltimore Represents !

FIJM | Brandon Woody’s Upendo: Baltimore Represents !

FIJM | Stella Cole: From Tik Tok to The Biggest Jazz Stages

FIJM | Stella Cole: From Tik Tok to The Biggest Jazz Stages

ALICE on Her X

ALICE on Her X

FIJM  | Samara Joy: Pushing Classic Vocal Jazz Repertoire to its Limits

FIJM | Samara Joy: Pushing Classic Vocal Jazz Repertoire to its Limits

FIJM | Nas symphonic and Nas not symphonic

FIJM | Nas symphonic and Nas not symphonic

Suoni | The Jellicle KIKI Ball #2 – Feline Grace is Served

Suoni | The Jellicle KIKI Ball #2 – Feline Grace is Served

Suoni | The Dark, Wicked, Warm and Absurd on the Same Dish

Suoni | The Dark, Wicked, Warm and Absurd on the Same Dish

Subscribe to our newsletter