Lizée, Holst, OSM : comet, planets, spaceship

by Frédéric Cardin

It was a very colorful evening at the Maison symphonique on Wednesday, September 27. On the program: Blurr is the Color of my True Love’s Eyes, the concerto for percussion and orchestra by Quebecer Nicole Lizée (performed for the first time in Quebec), and Gustav Holst’s famous Planets. On the podium was Gemma New, a young New Zealand-born conductor currently at the helm of the Hamilton Philharmonic. The latter showed great qualities, with precise, nervous conducting and a personal commitment that went beyond her little dance steps. Her delicate physique vibrated in tune with her solid mastery of discourse and nuances, well followed by the musicians.

Lizée’s Concerto, which you are invited to get to know better by reading the interview I conducted with the composer just a few days ago, is a magnificent, organized chaos. A work bursting with ribbed textures and colors, it derives as much from the soloist’s impressive assemblage (marimba, tubular bells, xylophone, drums, synthesizer, guitar! and a host of other weirdos) as from the orchestra itself. The basic matrix is a series of constantly changing, but perpetually repeated orchestral motifs, in the style of the American minimalist school (Glass, Reich), over which, or between which, the soloist struggles to bang and clap and color the sound space in every conceivable way (He hits a guitar and, elsewhere, Brian Manker’s cello, the orchestra’s first chair!). Perhaps the balance needs fine-tuning (in the rendering? In the writing?), as some of the soloist’s interventions were occasionally lost in the orchestral mass.

Despite the bursts of timbre and sonority coming from the orchestra, the Concerto’s overall framework is pulsating, even groovy, throughout (some 30 minutes). We nod pleasantly as if we were in a tank spitting out bouncy bass. Fortunately, Lizée’s is infinitely more subtle, if resolutely felt. Let’s talk about the soloist: Colin Currie. It was he himself who premiered the work last year and who revived it here. The pleasure of the performance lies as much in the sounds he creates with his vast instrumentation, but also in the sometimes frantic runs he has to make between the parts of the set-up (placed on either side of the conductor)! Respect.

This is certainly a milestone, I think, in the still occasional repertoire of great percussion concertos. Nicole Lizée and her Blurr is the Color of my True Love’s Eyes will go down in history. I loved it, and the audience gave a long round of applause for the artists who took to the stage.

The crowd was made up of a large number of young people, which was great to see.
They were obviously from high school bands or music programs, as they were attentive and frankly impressed.

In the second half, we were treated to Holst’s lively Planets.Gemma New resumed with the same energy, launching Mars, the War Bearer.Perhaps a little too hastily, as the first few seconds seemed to veer towards loss of control.Fortunately, things settled down very quickly.The young conductor convinced the orchestra to shine, with many dynamic shifts and nuances of color and texture.I have very little to say that would bring substantial downsides to this exciting performance.


I was with my son, and we had a lot of fun. That’s how we like our symphony evenings!
The concert will be repeated in its entirety on Sunday at 2.30pm.Bring your teen, especially if he or she loves film music!

Latest 360 Content

Violons du Roy at Bourgie: symphonic excitement from Old France

Violons du Roy at Bourgie: symphonic excitement from Old France

Piknic in June According to Mathieu Constance: Follow The PRO!

Piknic in June According to Mathieu Constance: Follow The PRO!

Festival Classica | Marianne Lambert Gives Voice to Perinatal Grief

Festival Classica | Marianne Lambert Gives Voice to Perinatal Grief

Festival Classica | Patrick Mathieu on Children’s Perspective

Festival Classica | Patrick Mathieu on Children’s Perspective

Concerts de Saint-Grégoire at Cadet Roussel Farm: “Quest to Reconcile Apparent Contrasts “

Concerts de Saint-Grégoire at Cadet Roussel Farm: “Quest to Reconcile Apparent Contrasts “

C la vie: The never-ending drum dance to close out FTA

C la vie: The never-ending drum dance to close out FTA

SAT Domesicle | Vancouver’s Normie Corp Immersion in MTL

SAT Domesicle | Vancouver’s Normie Corp Immersion in MTL

Festival Classica | Marie-Nicole Lemieux and the torero side of Carmen

Festival Classica | Marie-Nicole Lemieux and the torero side of Carmen

Nuits d’Afrique 2025: Flavia Coelho Presents Ginga

Nuits d’Afrique 2025: Flavia Coelho Presents Ginga

Colonial Shadows, Ancestral Light: The Politics of “Wayqeycuna”

Colonial Shadows, Ancestral Light: The Politics of “Wayqeycuna”

Ambre Ciel, Peaceful Melodies Between Sky and Sea

Ambre Ciel, Peaceful Melodies Between Sky and Sea

Backxwash – Only Dust Remains

Backxwash – Only Dust Remains

Rebecca Foon & Aliayta Foon-Dancoes – Reverie

Rebecca Foon & Aliayta Foon-Dancoes – Reverie

Misc – Beat Bouquet

Misc – Beat Bouquet

Heaven FM – A Surreal Broadcast from the Beyond

Heaven FM – A Surreal Broadcast from the Beyond

Guillaume Lefebvre – Au loin

Guillaume Lefebvre – Au loin

Angel Wang; Phoenix Orchestra – Phoenix Rising

Angel Wang; Phoenix Orchestra – Phoenix Rising

CMIM 2025 | Assessment of a Successful First Event

CMIM 2025 | Assessment of a Successful First Event

The Centre des Musiciens du Monde’s music Tree that brings people together

The Centre des Musiciens du Monde’s music Tree that brings people together

Festival Classica | Pavane For a Flaxen-Haired Gypsy Girl

Festival Classica | Pavane For a Flaxen-Haired Gypsy Girl

Festival des Saveurs | Carminda Mac Lorin, The Woman of Many Hats

Festival des Saveurs | Carminda Mac Lorin, The Woman of Many Hats

SAT X EAF | Amselysen and The Ideal Perfume of A Serial Killer

SAT X EAF | Amselysen and The Ideal Perfume of A Serial Killer

Festival Classica 2025 | Women’s Cellos

Festival Classica 2025 | Women’s Cellos

Subscribe to our newsletter