I Gemelli in Montreal: Simply One of the Year’s Great Concerts

by Frédéric Cardin

It was one of the most beautiful evenings of music I’ve heard this year. If an Opus Prize could be awarded to the best concert in Montreal by a foreign organization, I Gemelli at Salle Bourgie last Wednesday evening (November 22) would be among the few finalists. I Gemelli is an ensemble led by Emiliano Gonzalez Toro, a tenor with a wide range (a barytenor, in fact) and a stage presence that is easy, dynamic and more than likeable. On stage, another tenor, Zachary Wilder, is lighter and brighter, but just as technically and expressively impressive. For this concert of Italian baroque arias (essentially, the programme from their album A Room of Mirrors), they were accompanied by a baroque cello, a viola da gamba, two violins, a harpsichord, a harp, a theorbo or a baroque guitar (the musician changed depending on the piece) and an archlute, the ensemble I Gemelli.

To say it was good is too generic. Call it what you will, the mayo that catches, the current that flows, a home run on almost every ”tune”, in short, it was memorable. Firstly, because the musicians are all good, very good. The two tenors stand out, as they are often in the spotlight in this predominantly vocal repertoire. Like the mirrors in the title of the eponymous album, they are both capable of the most exquisite subtlety in triple pianissimo (in the treble, please (!), but they still surprise in their complementarity, thus avoiding duplication. The instrumentalists are at the pinnacle of an art that is now well mastered, the historical baroque, but they seem to have taken it to a new level in terms of technical perfection and authentic affect. The overall sound of these Gemelli is finely graduated and balanced, demonstrating a remarkably coherent collective listening.

And then there’s the programme. I’ve said a little bit about it, but it’s worth highlighting the audacity of coming to a city for the first time with a line-up that doesn’t have any real ‘selling’ names! No Vivaldi, no Bach, not even Corelli. No, just Falconieri, d’India, Marini, Castellani, and the other greats of their time, now retreating into obscurity. And yet, I don’t think any other meeting with more eminent ‘celebrities’ would have been more satisfying. What we heard was beautifully inspired, with strong melodies and fine compositions that were by turns invigorating or poignant. A feast from start to finish.

But the real soul of this memorable concert came from the musicians themselves. Artists who enjoy playing together and show it clearly – isn’t that, in the final analysis, an excellent sign? Then there was Toro himself (ably assisted by Wilder), who dared to do something that few Europeans still do, especially those of such high calibre as these: address the audience directly, throughout the concert. The communication is fluid, friendly but not overdramatic, and informative but in no way academic. It’s fun but with a clear respect for the audience’s intelligence.

And believe me, the audience really appreciated it. After the concert, the musicians rushed into the lobby of the venue to talk to the public and sell a few albums. There was a big crowd around the table and, if I’m not mistaken, the well-stocked box was emptied in no time. Even the beautiful box set of Monteverdi’s Il ritorno d’Ulisse in patria, which was recently released and cost $60, was gone. I got a copy, signed and kindly given to me by Toro himself. The man is happy.

These people know how to make friends, and they’ve given us good reason to invite them back.

Latest 360 Content

Orchestre Tout Puissant Marcel Duchamp – Ventre Unique

Orchestre Tout Puissant Marcel Duchamp – Ventre Unique

Fantastic Negrito – Son of A Broken Man

Fantastic Negrito – Son of A Broken Man

Cumbia, Chaos, and Resistance: Empanadas Illegales Bring the Heat to Montreal Jazz Fest

Cumbia, Chaos, and Resistance: Empanadas Illegales Bring the Heat to Montreal Jazz Fest

Turnstile – Never Enough

Turnstile – Never Enough

FIJM | Dianne Reeves and Romero Lubambo: An Intimate Duo of Virtuosos

FIJM | Dianne Reeves and Romero Lubambo: An Intimate Duo of Virtuosos

FIJM | Brandon Woody’s Upendo: Baltimore Represents !

FIJM | Brandon Woody’s Upendo: Baltimore Represents !

FIJM | Stella Cole: From Tik Tok to The Biggest Jazz Stages

FIJM | Stella Cole: From Tik Tok to The Biggest Jazz Stages

ALICE on Her X

ALICE on Her X

FIJM  | Samara Joy: Pushing Classic Vocal Jazz Repertoire to its Limits

FIJM | Samara Joy: Pushing Classic Vocal Jazz Repertoire to its Limits

FIJM | Nas symphonic and Nas not symphonic

FIJM | Nas symphonic and Nas not symphonic

Suoni | The Jellicle KIKI Ball #2 – Feline Grace is Served

Suoni | The Jellicle KIKI Ball #2 – Feline Grace is Served

Suoni | The Dark, Wicked, Warm and Absurd on the Same Dish

Suoni | The Dark, Wicked, Warm and Absurd on the Same Dish

FIJM | Azimuth: Brazilian Jazz Fusion of the Highest Order

FIJM | Azimuth: Brazilian Jazz Fusion of the Highest Order

FIJM | Anomalie and Lewis: Two hour Jam by Two Heavy Hitters

FIJM | Anomalie and Lewis: Two hour Jam by Two Heavy Hitters

FIJM | Thanya Iyer and Arooj Aftab, Perfect Transplants!

FIJM | Thanya Iyer and Arooj Aftab, Perfect Transplants!

Festival de Lanaudière | Renaud Loranger Explains The Program

Festival de Lanaudière | Renaud Loranger Explains The Program

FIJM | Kojo Melché Roney, Born to Drum

FIJM | Kojo Melché Roney, Born to Drum

FIJM 2025 | King Makaya triumphs again

FIJM 2025 | King Makaya triumphs again

FIJM | It’s About Time to Ackowledge Peter Evans Fabulous Playing

FIJM | It’s About Time to Ackowledge Peter Evans Fabulous Playing

FIJM | Yasmin Williams: Reinventing The Guitar!

FIJM | Yasmin Williams: Reinventing The Guitar!

FIJM | Natalia Lafourcade Sparks a Place des Arts Gone Mexican

FIJM | Natalia Lafourcade Sparks a Place des Arts Gone Mexican

FIJM | Clown Core: the theatre of extremes, between Pennywise and Krusty

FIJM | Clown Core: the theatre of extremes, between Pennywise and Krusty

Domaine Forget | A Summer of Discovery

Domaine Forget | A Summer of Discovery

FIJM | Wynton & JLCO: Something of an Opening Ceremony

FIJM | Wynton & JLCO: Something of an Opening Ceremony

Subscribe to our newsletter